Quests

Most progression in How to Fish runs through NPC quests, and a few of them are genuinely confusing — items that do not say where they drop, turn-ins that reject the obvious item. Each guide here answers one quest blocker directly, with screenshots of the actual locations.

Where do I find 5 leeches?
Which item is the Pufferfish Trophy?

Section last updated Aug 22, 2026

The leech quest NPC sitting by the water on the second island in How to Fish with a Talk prompt

Quests · Updated Aug 22

Where to Find 5 Leeches in How to Fish

Quest blocker · Island 2

The Pufferfish Fin quest item lying on the beach in How to Fish with its pickup prompt visible

Quests · Updated Aug 22

Pufferfish Trophy: Which Item Do You Turn In?

Quest item confusion · Island 3

New here? Start with Where to Find 5 Leeches.